23 November 2023

Understand the Transition Spectrum with the Shades of Green

S&P Global Ratings provides independent, transparent opinions on a company's financing or framework, grounded in its award-winning Shades of Green approach, which assess the extent of contribution to a sustainable future.

Despite stagnating global bond issuance, S&P Global Ratings' research anticipates that GSSSB (green, social, sustainable, and sustainability-linked bonds) issuance should be in line with our forecast of $900 billion to $1 trillion, or 14% to 16% of total issuance, in 2023.

We anticipate issuance of sustainability-linked bonds will decline in 2023 as questions regarding the credibility of targets persist, while green bonds will continue to dominate the GSSSB market, building on a record level of issuance in the first half of the year. Europe will remain the leading region for GSSSBs, while North American issuance may be hampered by lower supply and demand for the remainder of the year. Emerging markets may see increased issuance in the coming year.

GSSSB issuance totals are forecast to increase by 5%-17% in 2023 versus 2022

Note: Excludes structered finance. Data for 2023 combines January-June results our forecasts for the full year. f--S&P Global Ratings forecast. GSSSB--Green, social, sustainable, and sustainability-linked bonds. Sources: Environmental Finance Data. S&P Global Ratings.Copyright © 2023 by Standards and Poor's Financial Services LLC. All rights reserved  

Green bonds remain the leading GSSSB category, at 59% of issuance in H1 2023. Green bonds are likely to continue to dominate, as sustainability-linked bonds falter. Green bond issuance during the first half of 2023 reached $310 billion, marking the highest half-year total since the inception of the green bond market. Green bonds have comprised 59% of the GSSSB market in 2023 so far. We predict they will remain prevalent through the rest of the year. Nonfinancial corporates are currently the largest issuers of green bonds, despite issuance contracting 6% compared with the first half of 2022.

Sustainability-linked bond (SLB) issuance continues to lag other bond types and will likely not reach 2022 levels. Issuance for the year is likely to be $33 billion, accounting for 6% of all GSSSB issuance, down from a high of 9% in 2021. Notably, more than 99% of SLB issuance this year was from nonfinancial corporates, compared with 88% in 2022. SLB issuance from other types of entities has all but disappeared. Financial services, sovereign, and US and international public finance entities issued less than $200 million (0.4%) of SLBs in the first half of 2023.

Questions persist about whether SLBs motivate issuers to set ambitious sustainability targets. These concerns have persisted for more than a year, as stakeholders have expressed doubts about whether the structural and financial features associated with missing targets give issuers sufficient incentive to achieve them. For example, there is increasing sensitivity from stakeholders on targets related to Scope 3 greenhouse gas emissions. These emissions are indirect and can originate in companies' value chains or during the end-use of their products.

Read the full report for other key trends in GSSSB issuance here.

Second Party Opinions, featuring Shades of Green

An S&P Global Ratings Second Party Opinion (SPO) is an independent, point-in-time analysis of a sustainable finance instrument, programme, or framework.

One feature that sets apart an S&P Global Ratings Second Party Opinion (SPO) is that, we apply our award-winning Shades of Green approach to give an opinion of how consistent green financing activities are with a low-carbon climate resilient future. Our SPOs assess the financing's contribution to transitioning to a more sustainable future through our shading scale, which includes assigning Dark, Medium or Light shading as appropriate. Thus, Light Green may motivate early movers and helps to recognize transition steps in the near-term, while Dark Green acknowledges those closer to the end of their transition journey.

Learn more about our Second Party Opinions and the Shades of Green scale, or get in touch with us directly.

Get in touch with us

Channels: 
Green Bonds
Companies: 
S&P Global Ratings
Sponsored by
Contact
Latest Stories
  • Sustainable bonds 'more attractive' to investors if primary spend is clear, says APG

    01 November 2024

    Sustainable bond issuers have been urged to make it clear to investors where they primarily intend to allocate spending, according to pension fund investment firm APG - even if such guidance has to be qualitative rather than quantitative.

  • European Leaders at COP16 are Helping Protect Indigenous Lands

    01 November 2024

    Protecting 30% of the Earth should not mean expelling Indigenous Peoples and local communities from their land, write Dr. James C. Deutsch and Dr. Viviana Figueroa

  • From COP to coop

    01 November 2024

    While COP16 is important, it is also worth paying attention to a bond issue from a UK chicken producer, write Ulf Erlandsson and Trisha Hutchinson

  • Impact could top 15% of UK's total AUM by 2030, investors predict

    01 November 2024
  • Gaps remain despite progress on PAI reporting, as regulators told to step up scrutiny

    01 November 2024

    Gaps remain in financial institutions' reporting of the 'principal adverse impacts' (PAIs) of investments, and despite gradual improvements in some areas EU regulators were told to "increasingly challenge" investors on their reporting.